Recent

Check Out Our Forum Tab!

Click On The "Forum" Tab Under The Logo For More Content!
If you are using your phone, click on the menu, then select forum. Make sure you refresh the page!

The views of the poster, may not be the views of the website of "Minnesota Outdoorsman" therefore we are not liable for what our members post, they are solely responsible for what they post. They agreed to a user agreement when signing up to MNO.

Author Topic: Any guess on this guys age? What he'd score?  (Read 3838 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Offline sjohnnie26

  • Xtreme Outdoorsman
  • Posts: 196
  • Karma: +0/-0
« Last Edit: September 09/25/08, 08:35:23 AM by Tim »
"AIM SMALL, MISS SMALL"  -Jeff Simpson

Offline rod-man

  • Outdoorsman
  • Posts: 90
  • Karma: +0/-0
Be safe  share the water <*)}}}}}><~~~~

Offline Don Stenseth

  • Xtreme Outdoorsman
  • Posts: 379
  • Karma: +0/-0
    • Don Stenseth's Wildlife Photos
Tough to score without seeing the browe tines or the width of the rack but if I had to guess I would call him 3 1/2 years with a score of maybe 115
Don Stenseth's Wildlife Photos

www.sitekreator.com/donstenseth

Offline Spinach

  • Outdoorsman
  • Posts: 13
  • Karma: +8/-7
  • Woodbury Mn
MNO Fishing Reports
Voted #1 Outdoors Website in MN
Support MNO Sponsors
AKA "Spinach"

Offline 22lex

  • Master Outdoorsman
  • Posts: 926
  • Karma: +0/-0
  • Photo-op
3 1/2 and 115-120 I think.

I'm about right there with you on that one Pat.
Marry an outdoors woman. Then if you throw her out into the yard on a cold night, she can still survive.
-WC Fields

Offline wischunter08

  • Outdoorsman
  • Posts: 75
  • Karma: +0/-0

Offline Big E

  • Xtreme Outdoorsman
  • Posts: 364
  • Karma: +0/-0
That's a pretty big body on him. Legs to me look short and the stomach already has a sag on it. Brisket is saggy and shoulders look really defined so I'm gonna say 3 1/2 possibly 4 1/2 but it's tough from this angle because you can't see the back sag much. The rack looks small because the body is so big. So I'd say 130. It's a shooter for sure in my opinion.
Let the small bucks walk. Don't assume the neighbors will shoot them if you don't. If you shoot him what chance does that buck have to grow......ZERO!

Offline HD

  • Administrator
  • Master Outdoorsman
  • *
  • Posts: 15834
  • Karma: +57/-23
  • #1 Judge (Retired)
    • Minnesota Outdoorsman
4 1/2
135............can't see the brow's, so, I'm assuming they are short.
Mama always said, If you ain't got noth'in nice to say, don't say noth'in at all!

Offline sjohnnie26

  • Xtreme Outdoorsman
  • Posts: 196
  • Karma: +0/-0
Hopefully he'll walk under the stand during hunting hours, so far he's only moving at night.  Thanks to everyone for your opinions, I am not too good at aging/scoring yet.  All I know is that he's a shooter in my book!
"AIM SMALL, MISS SMALL"  -Jeff Simpson

Offline bowhunter73

  • Master Outdoorsman
  • Posts: 547
  • Karma: +0/-0
  • Cedar, MN Member #113
3 1/2  not over 120  a bit short on mass

 Could you tell us more about this deer.

What part of the state?
Public or private land?
If private how much land
Food plots?

 With this knowledge, I would like to see people’s opinion on whether or not they would shoot him or give him another year. There is no wrong answer here just wondering.

I hunt on many different lands and on most of them I would most likely shoot him .But on the land I am trying to manage I think I would let him go.
Are you a hunter or do you just kill things? Respect the wildlife!

Online deadeye

  • MNO Moderator
  • Master Outdoorsman
  • *
  • Posts: 6212
  • Karma: +19/-13
I'd guess him to be 3.5 years old and around the low to mid 130's.  If I had not taken any deer yet and the season was winding down, I would most likely take him.  If on the other hand, I had already taken a buck, (party hunting) I would probably let him go.  I know this because that's exactly what happend last year.  I killed a nice 8 point on the first weekend of rifle season.  On the last Saturday I watched a big guy (probably a little bigger than the one in the pic) chase a doe across a swamp and into the island I was on.  Had a shot but let it go for a couple reasons. I was still bow hunting and planned to muzzle hunt later.  Also, my son was not to far away and he had not shot a buck yet so I though he may get a crack at this one. 
P.S. As far as I know nobody took this one so I hope he's still around.
***I started out with nothing, and I still have most of it.***

Offline DroptineDC18

  • Outdoorsman
  • Posts: 65
  • Karma: +0/-0
This deer is probably 3 1/2 and on the low 130's, like most people have said. This deer does have a big body, but his rack does not look proportional to it.  Looking at this picture, I probably would not shoot him.  However, I have seen many bucks that look smaller on trail cams but when they are on the hoof or dead they are much bigger.  A for instance is last year when my buddy's dad had a nice 10 point on a trail cam, we all guessed it to be in the mid 130's.  But when he shot him during the rut it ended up scoring in the low 150's.  Needless to say he was pleasantly surprised.  Some people would let it go in the early season and then shoot him later in the year. I don't understand why people do this.  If you want to grow bigger bucks the ones that are passed on early need to be let go the entire year.  If it is meat people need then does are a lot better tasting.  That's our philosophy.  If we make the decision not to shoot him the first time we see him(assuming he presents a shot and you get a good look at him) he is off limits until next year.  We are definitely seeing the benefits of this!
"One of the most common causes of failure is the habit of quitting when one is overtaken by temporary defeat." -Napoleon Hill

Offline Cody Gruchow

  • Master Outdoorsman
  • Posts: 4060
  • Karma: +3/-0
  • 2016 Mno rockbass challenge champion
4 and a half, maybe 130-135. not to much mass, but the body on him is impressive. if he is 4 and half and he is sporting that rack i would take him, but thats just me

Offline Auggie

  • Master Outdoorsman
  • Posts: 1133
  • Karma: +7/-1
  • Start'em young
    • www.wallhangerstaxidermystudio.com
3 1/2 years old. Might make 120. Poor tine length not one over 7.5 inches. light on the mass and width.
Shane Augeson
Wallhangers Taxidermy Studio
9040 40th St NW
Milan MN 56262
www.wallhangerstaxidermystudio.com
320-269-3337

Offline dseifert6

  • Posts: 1
  • Karma: +0/-0
I'd say hes 4.5 years for sure....not sure on the score....you can tell he's an older deer by the way the skin sags of his shoulders there....not much mass in the rack so it probably wouldn't score too high....Not saying I wouldn't shoot him though :)

Offline MN RACK ATTACK

  • Xtreme Outdoorsman
  • Posts: 455
  • Karma: +2/-1
I agree with Auggie. it would be pushing it to get it to make 120. Ive got a 8 point with 11 1/2" g2's and it only goes 138. he would be hard to pass up though. If its on public land I would take him.

 :rocker;
2020 Big Buck Slayer