Simple Debate

[HD]

A or B, and why?

[attachment deleted by admin]

[glenn57]

Both... party hunting  seriously though that's a really tough call but I'd probably pick B. The rack appears bigger with more points. May be non-typical.

[Boar]

I like the split tines on B

[glenn57]

I like the split tines on B

to bad you're gonna get buck fever and either miss or not shoot at all!!!!

[Boar]

ooooh and i wasnbeing nice about your weekend ladies aid quiltimg B going on. grrrrrrrr. lol

[deadeye]

I would go with B. Seems to be more mass and more unique with stickers and drops.

[markn]

I'm with deadeye on this and for same reasons. B. A isn't too bad either.

[The General]

B here too.

[corky]

B - the mass stood out at first glance.

[gophergunner]

Which ever one presents the best shot.  As should be the case, I'm more concerned with making a clean kill than counting points and envisioning mounts.

[proangler16]

Which ever one presents the best shot.  As should be the case, I'm more concerned with making a clean kill than counting points and envisioning mounts.

I'd agree here, if the shot only presented itself there for a split second shot, I'd have to go for A depending on the distance, more mass and vitals for the shot but depending on ones skills and comfort level with weapon, I'd have to go for B.

[dew2]

A or B, and why?

Neither!! The season is closed
 The B shot will ruin lots a meat in comparison to A. B shot is right down the innerds an poop shoot,What a mess to clean out!!
 Besides I quit huntin horns years ago.

[glenn57]

  :banghead:sheez, youz guys are getting way to technical! it was a simple question. Which one and why. Not cause of the angle of the dangle if the shot. besides I be betting that picture was photo shopped . Judging by the color of the leaves in the background I'd be betting that 2 bucks of that nature wouldn't be best buds like that!!;

[dew2]

  besides I be betting that picture was photo shopped . Judging by the color of the leaves in the background I'd be betting that 2 bucks of that nature wouldn't be best buds like that!!;

57 you dazzle me with yer brilliance>>PHOTO SHOPPED
 COLOR A DA LEAVES???

 Look at the shadows of their snouts

[deadeye]

Although it's probably not the point, it is without a doubt photo shopped.  Good catch Glenn57.  I would still first shoot the one with the biggest antlers (B) then turn my attention to the more inferior buck.  That is if I didn't panic and drop my weapon first!

[Reinhard]

I would take either one.  I hunt way up north, way back in the woods.  I have seen some big brute's like these but never got a good shot at them.  Dont see too many of them to get a chance.  The way I look at it is, if I do get a clean shot at one and harvest it, it's a bonus.  I'm happy with bringing some venison home and being with the guy's at deer camp.  They are both great looking deer.  good luck.